Don’t Correct Everything You Hear

A conductor hears a lot! (or, at least: they should hear a lot...) 

And once a conductor has trained their ear to hear mistakes, it can become tempting to try to fix everything at once, or to impress the choir with the amount of mistakes one can identify. 

Imagine this scene: 

[CHOIR SINGS. DIRECTOR GRIMACES AND STOPS THE CHOIR.] 

“Okay, everyone! The tenor vowel is different from everyone else’s. The altos are late on the entrance. Sopranos, too heavy. Basses, watch the accidentals, you sang wrong notes at measure four. Everyone, the phrase needs more direction. The chord is not quite balanced. Also, keep the words in mind. We want to really help people feel this. Okay, let’s try it again!” 

All of those observations may be correct. But will the choir remember all of this? Will you? Are all these mistakes of equal value?   

One of the hardest rehearsal skills to develop is not hearing problems. It is deciding which problem matters most. 

 

Every Stop Has a Price 

When we stop the choir, we interrupt something.  

We interrupt the musical line. We interrupt the physical act of singing. And every time we speak, we ask singers to shift their attention from making music to processing information. 

Sometimes that interruption is necessary. But if a conductor stops for every imperfection, rehearsal can become a series of corrections rather than a process of making music. 

The goal is not to ignore mistakes. It is to put them in order. Before stopping, ask: What am I trying to accomplish in this rehearsal right now? 

If the choir is learning notes and rhythms, an imperfect vowel may be able to wait. 

If the purpose of the repetition is tuning, a ragged final consonant may not be the most important problem. 

If singers are finally beginning to sustain a long phrase, this may not be the moment to interrupt them because one section missed a dynamic.  

Not every problem deserves equal attention at every stage of rehearsal! 

 

Establish a Rehearsal Hierarchy 

I think that a useful rehearsal plan has priorities. In general, I use the following hierarchy of rehearsal needs: 

Pitch, rhythmic, and phrasal accuracy --> Vocal and choral tone --> Intonation and balance --> Consonant diction --> Dynamic contrast  --> Meaning and text interpretation 

I find that beginning conductors rush to the end of the hierarchy before pitches and rhythms have been corrected. We like to talk about meaning; we like to get singers excited about music. We like to inspire, and we want our singers to feel about the music the way that we feel when we love a piece of music. 

But think logically: if you're singing a wrong note, does anyone care if the words are pronounced well?  Can you really address diction when the rhythm is wrong? Do you need to add a crescendo to an ugly sound? (really, I think most choirs could spend 90% of their time focused on the first two elements of the hierarchy and they’d achieve better results...) 

Understanding the hierarchy makes corrections clearer for singers. When every repetition comes with five unrelated instructions, singers have to decide what to remember. When the conductor identifies one or two primary objectives for the rehearsal, the ensemble can focus its attention and hear whether the next attempt actually improved. 

“Let’s do that again” becomes much more useful when everyone knows what the next repetition is for. 

I’d add two notes on this hierarchy: first, it is possible to layer in multiple elements of the hierarchy, once you understand the goal. It just needs to be mindful. Perhaps most of the choir needs to focus on pitch and rhythm, but your leaders can think about phrasing. 

Second: note that I place phrasal accuracy in the same place as rhythmic and pitch accuracy. I personally think that phrasing is sorely neglected in the beginning of the rehearsal process. So many dynamic and intonation issues can be addressed by thinking about phrases correctly. 

 

Some Problems Solve Other Problems 

There is another reason not to correct everything immediately: the right correction often fixes several things at once. 

A pronunciation problem may disappear once singers understand the rhythm. 

An intonation problem may improve when the phrase is sung with a healthy vocal tone. 

A balance problem may resolve when singers understand which voice has the important material. 

A difficult high note may become easier when the choir learns to manage the phrase leading into it.  

 

A Rehearsal Reconsidered 

Let’s go back to our original scenario. Let’s imagine this scene: 

[DIRECTOR ADDRESSES THE CHOIR] 

“Folks, we had a great first rehearsal last week. We made excellent project on pitch and rhythm. Because we only have four rehearsals remaining, let’s think about what we need to accomplish tonight. Let’s really focus tonight on solidifying our pitch and rhythm, particularly on pages 5 and 6. As we work on this, we’ll start on a neutral syllable for a unified sound. Once we get the notes in shape, we’ll shift to text. Ready?” 

The choir knows what to focus on. This is a learning rehearsal. Most people will focus on pitch and rhythm, but we’re layering in some work on unity and tone. Work on text will follow (continuing this work on tonal unity). Balance, dynamics, and interpretation might be layered in, but not at the expense of this work on the foundation. 

There may not be one magic thing to focus on that fixes every problem in every piece for every choir. But there should be a focus for this rehearsal. 

Remember: good rehearsal technique is not the ability to identify every flaw in real time. It is the ability to decide what the ensemble needs next. The rest can wait its turn. 

 

About the Author

Richard W. Robbins

Richard W. Robbins is an award-winning conductor, scholar, educator, and choral editor whose work spans professional, collegiate, church, school, and community ensembles. He serves as Director and James Erb Choral Chair of the Richmond Symphony Chorus and as Choral Editor and Market Development Manager at OCP Choral, where he helps connect conductors with meaningful, practical, and artistically compelling repertoire.

Back to blog